2021

• Jordan Martinez - Lasell University
• Ian Bello - Baseball, Westminster College
• Dwight Zafra - Baseball, Norwich University
• Sammy Townsend - Basketball, William Peace University
• Matt Riley - Baseball, Queens University

2020

• Amie Bruton - Volleyball, Lynn University
• Isabella Garcia - Volleyball, College of Mount 
• Joseph DiNorcia - Baseball, College of Mount St. Vincent 
• Brandon Espinosa - Baseball, Montreat College
• Ryan Talano - Tennis, Oxford College at Emory University 
• JJ Garcia - Basketball, Dakota College at Bottineau 
• Srdjan Kopunovic - Basketball, Ellsworth College
• Chrisitan Fischer - Soccer, Bellarmine University 

2019

• Andrew Geiger: Baseball, College of Mount Saint Vincent
• Jayson Iten: Golf, Nova Southeastern University
• Josh Powers: Triathlon, Queens University of Charlotte
• Jovan Stulic: Basketball, University of Arkansas – Little Rock
• Blake Wheeler: Golf, Liberty University
• Emily Wisser: Softball, Rosemont College

2018

• Chase Bigham: Golf, Florida Gulf Coast University
• Emma Bradley: Golf, University of Mississippi
• Peter Charles: Cross Country/Track, Barton College
• Erick Chavez: Baseball, Hillsborough College
• Alegra d'Alessandro: Tennis, Wagner College
• Gem Grimshaw: Volleyball, Temple University
• Matt Hurley: Baseball, Rollins College
• Zack Maxson: Soccer, Shorter University
• Andrew Miller: Baseball, Hillsborough College
• David Morgan: Golf, University of Virginia
• Skyler Sieber: Volleyball, University of Montevallo
• Jared Farrow - Eastern Illinois for swimming

2017

• Matthew DiNorcia: Baseball, College of Mount St. Vincent
• Jarene Harberts: Volleyball, Simmons College
• Piper Matsumoto: Volleyball, Long Island University
• Lennard Pietersz: Baseball, Western Oklahoma State
• Josue Rivera: Baseball, Bethune-Cookman University

2016

• Charleigh Crews: Volleyball, University of New Haven
• Alex Farrow: Diving, University of Florida
• Emily Hancock: Volleyball, Berry College (Ga.)
• Tyler Lopes: Baseball, Johnson University
• Anna-Marie Kuenzle: Golf, High Point University
• Abby O'Hara: Soccer, Franklin & Marshall College
• Kelly Worthington: Tennis, Southern Virginia University

2015

• Trey Brown: Swimming, Marymount University
• Tori Davis: Sailing, Georgetown University
• David DiNorcia: Baseball, Le Moyne College
• Valerie Gonzalez: Volleyball, Radford University

2014

• Maddie Butehorn: Equestrian sports, University of South Carolina
• Alec Da Silveira: Cross Country & Track, DePauw University
• Dane Erickson: Swimming, Massachusetts Institute of Technology
• Andrew LeMay: Cross Country & Track, St. Norbert College

2013

• Donato DiNorcia: Baseball, Le Moyne College
• Tim Flynn: Baseball, Grove City College
• Elliot Gonzalez: Baseball, Palm Beach Atlantic University
• Jay Jenkins: Baseball, Flagler College
• William Luer: Track, Washington University in St. Louis
• CJ Price: Baseball, Washington University in St. Louis; Cornell University
• Jimmy Quattrocchi: Baseball, Rhodes College

2012

• Kathryn Boll: Volleyball, Muhlenburg College
• Ann Murphy: Swimming, John Carroll University
• Jeffery Ortiz: Baseball, Broward College
• Sienna Purse: Softball, Sewanee University
• Hana Sladick: Track and Field, University of Florida
• Chandler Spearman: Volleyball, University of North Dakota

2011

• Ridge Altman: Swimming, University of Southern California
• Rachel Bales: Basketball, College of Wooster
• Manuela Burtscher: Track, University of Florida

2010

• Brunes Charles: Basketball, Newberry College
• Alexis Mastmeier: Tennis, Agnes Scott College

2008

• James Myers: Track & Cross Country, Rochester University
• Chelsea Preeg: Tennis, Vanderbilt University